Best Sellers

  • ORIGINAL

    POP Mustards Original

    The OG recipe that started it all is a perfect blend of whole mustard seeds and IPA that create citrus-floral flavor with a hint of hops. Pickled jalapeños and lime launch the flavor. Whether it’s a quick vinaigrette for scallops, added to you deviled eggs, or a restaurant quality garnish on smoked fish. POP ORIGINAL is your go-to mustard for next level happiness.

    CONTAINS GLUTEN

    POP Ingredients

    $6.99

  • SMOKED

    POP Mustard Smoked

    The art of smoke and BBQ is one of today’s hottest, most sought out food trends. SMOKED mustard does the work for you, bringing a subtle, smoke to your dish. Use it for your vegetarian friends that may not eat meat but still love its smokey goodness. SMOKED takes avocado toast or a tomato salad to new heights while being a natural on a burger.

    GLUTEN FREE

    POP Ingredients

    $6.99

Seasonal

  • FERMENTED

    POP Mustard Fermented

    Sauerkraut and mustard are such a classic combination. Add that unforgettable POP texture and the power of sour created through natural fermentation this mustard will make your next backyard cookout something to remember. We love the kraut slathered over some smoked pork, grilled kielbasa and of coarse a good old fashion classic hot dog!

    GLUTEN FREE

    POP Ingredients

    $6.99

  • 3 JAR GIFT BOX

    Pop Mustards gift box 3 pack
    Discover the Perfect Trio: POP Mustards 3-Pack Gift Box
    Elevate your culinary experience with our handcrafted POP Mustards gift box, featuring three distinctive flavors made right here in Cleveland, Ohio. This carefully curated collection includes our classic ORIGINAL (contains gluten), rich SMOKED, and our seasonal sensation FERMENTED mustard – each telling its own delicious story.
    What’s Inside: each 6 oz glass jar
    • ORIGINAL: Our flagship mustard that started it all – bold, zesty, and perfectly balanced
    • SMOKED: Deep, complex notes that add warmth and character to any dish
    • FERMENTED: Our seasonal offering that brings a tangy, fermented twist to traditional mustard
    These artisanal mustards are perfect for cheese boards, sandwiches, or as a gourmet cooking ingredient. Each jar is made with premium and all natural ingredients.
    Perfect for:
    • Food lovers and cooking enthusiasts
    • Unique

    ORIGINAL: CONTAINS GLUTEN
    SMOKED: GLUTEN FREE
    FERMENTED: GLUTEN FREE

    POP Ingredients

    $21.99